In a poignant reflection of the struggles faced by Americans burdened with student debt, the experiences of Elizabeth Hadzic and Kim Coles underscore the challenges within the bankruptcy court system as a means of relief.
Protesters gathered outside of the United States. Before the oral arguments in two instances challenging President Joe Biden’s $400 billion student loan forgiveness proposal, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in both cases. (Source: Megan Smith/USA Today)
Student Debt Challenges
Hadzic, a 50-year-old psychotherapist in Maryland, and Coles, a late 60s accountant from Oregon, found themselves in dire financial straits due to health issues and unemployment, respectively. Both shared the common thread of tens of thousands of dollars in student debt, compelling them to turn to the often arduous and expensive process of seeking loan discharge in bankruptcy court. While Hadzic’s story offers a glimmer of hope with her bankruptcy proceedings moving toward a full discharge, Coles faces resistance from the government, despite being at retirement age and maintaining a flawless record of timely payments for over a decade. The stark contrast in their experiences reflects the inherent challenges in accessing meaningful student debt relief, especially as the Biden administration grapples with alternatives following the Supreme Court’s rejection of sweeping loan forgiveness in June.
The historical rarity of successful student debt discharges in bankruptcy court, roughly one in a thousand cases, prompted the Justice Department to implement new guidance last year. Despite the department’s claim of success with approximately 630 cases in ten months, critics argue that the process is far from a comprehensive overhaul. Variables such as the assigned federal lawyer and jurisdiction continue to heavily influence outcomes, leaving room for disparities. As the Biden administration touts improvements, skeptics, including legal experts like Dalié Jiménez, caution that it might be premature to declare victory, emphasizing the persistent hardships faced by those seeking relief from the crushing weight of student debt.
The broader context highlights the extraordinary lengths many Americans go to manage the economic burdens of higher education, from juggling multiple jobs to residing with family. The road to relief through bankruptcy court remains a less traveled path, with critics pointing to abysmal success rates, lengthy processes, and exceptionally high legal standards for borrower qualification. Even President Joe Biden, who once supported legislation making the process tougher during his senatorial tenure, has evolved in his stance, pledging to rectify the “absurd rules” that nearly render the discharge of student debt impossible in bankruptcy court during his 2020 presidential campaign.
READ ALSO: Student Debt Relief Continues to Be A Bipartisan And High-Profile Debate
